Consumer Reports is not currently testing Toilet paper. Models in this ratings table may no longer be available or might have limited distribution. Please see our Toilet paper buying guide for more information.

Toilet paper

FILTER & COMPARE

VIEW
bath tissue
Toilet paper
Shop
Strength

Strength

Strength reflects resistance to puncturing.

 /  5
Softness

Softness

Softness is the judgment of trained panelists.

 /  5
Disintegration

Disintegration

Disintegration reflects the amount of time needed for a sheet to break up in swirling water.

 /  5
Tearing ease

Tearing ease

Tearing ease is based on the separation of sheets at their perforation.

 /  5
Basic
Toilet paper
Shop
Strength

Strength

Strength reflects resistance to puncturing.

 /  5
Softness

Softness

Softness is the judgment of trained panelists.

 /  5
Disintegration

Disintegration

Disintegration reflects the amount of time needed for a sheet to break up in swirling water.

 /  5
Tearing ease

Tearing ease

Tearing ease is based on the separation of sheets at their perforation.

 /  5
Ultra Soft
Toilet paper
Shop
Strength

Strength

Strength reflects resistance to puncturing.

 /  5
Softness

Softness

Softness is the judgment of trained panelists.

 /  5
Disintegration

Disintegration

Disintegration reflects the amount of time needed for a sheet to break up in swirling water.

 /  5
Tearing ease

Tearing ease

Tearing ease is based on the separation of sheets at their perforation.

 /  5
Ultra Strong
Toilet paper
Shop
Strength

Strength

Strength reflects resistance to puncturing.

 /  5
Softness

Softness

Softness is the judgment of trained panelists.

 /  5
Disintegration

Disintegration

Disintegration reflects the amount of time needed for a sheet to break up in swirling water.

 /  5
Tearing ease

Tearing ease

Tearing ease is based on the separation of sheets at their perforation.

 /  5
CleanCare
Toilet paper
Shop
Strength

Strength

Strength reflects resistance to puncturing.

 /  5
Softness

Softness

Softness is the judgment of trained panelists.

 /  5
Disintegration

Disintegration

Disintegration reflects the amount of time needed for a sheet to break up in swirling water.

 /  5
Tearing ease

Tearing ease

Tearing ease is based on the separation of sheets at their perforation.

 /  5
Ultra ComfortCare
Toilet paper
Shop
Strength

Strength

Strength reflects resistance to puncturing.

 /  5
Softness

Softness

Softness is the judgment of trained panelists.

 /  5
Disintegration

Disintegration

Disintegration reflects the amount of time needed for a sheet to break up in swirling water.

 /  5
Tearing ease

Tearing ease

Tearing ease is based on the separation of sheets at their perforation.

 /  5
Toilet paper
Toilet paper
Shop
Strength

Strength

Strength reflects resistance to puncturing.

 /  5
Softness

Softness

Softness is the judgment of trained panelists.

 /  5
Disintegration

Disintegration

Disintegration reflects the amount of time needed for a sheet to break up in swirling water.

 /  5
Tearing ease

Tearing ease

Tearing ease is based on the separation of sheets at their perforation.

 /  5
Premium Ultra
Toilet paper
Shop
Strength

Strength

Strength reflects resistance to puncturing.

 /  5
Softness

Softness

Softness is the judgment of trained panelists.

 /  5
Disintegration

Disintegration

Disintegration reflects the amount of time needed for a sheet to break up in swirling water.

 /  5
Tearing ease

Tearing ease

Tearing ease is based on the separation of sheets at their perforation.

 /  5
Ultra Plush
Toilet paper
Shop
Strength

Strength

Strength reflects resistance to puncturing.

 /  5
Softness

Softness

Softness is the judgment of trained panelists.

 /  5
Disintegration

Disintegration

Disintegration reflects the amount of time needed for a sheet to break up in swirling water.

 /  5
Tearing ease

Tearing ease

Tearing ease is based on the separation of sheets at their perforation.

 /  5
Ultra Soft & Strong with CleanStretch
Toilet paper
Shop
Strength

Strength

Strength reflects resistance to puncturing.

 /  5
Softness

Softness

Softness is the judgment of trained panelists.

 /  5
Disintegration

Disintegration

Disintegration reflects the amount of time needed for a sheet to break up in swirling water.

 /  5
Tearing ease

Tearing ease

Tearing ease is based on the separation of sheets at their perforation.

 /  5
1000
Toilet paper
Shop
Strength

Strength

Strength reflects resistance to puncturing.

 /  5
Softness

Softness

Softness is the judgment of trained panelists.

 /  5
Disintegration

Disintegration

Disintegration reflects the amount of time needed for a sheet to break up in swirling water.

 /  5
Tearing ease

Tearing ease

Tearing ease is based on the separation of sheets at their perforation.

 /  5
Extra Soft
Toilet paper
Shop
Strength

Strength

Strength reflects resistance to puncturing.

 /  5
Softness

Softness

Softness is the judgment of trained panelists.

 /  5
Disintegration

Disintegration

Disintegration reflects the amount of time needed for a sheet to break up in swirling water.

 /  5
Tearing ease

Tearing ease

Tearing ease is based on the separation of sheets at their perforation.

 /  5
Naturals Tube Free
Toilet paper
Shop
Strength

Strength

Strength reflects resistance to puncturing.

 /  5
Softness

Softness

Softness is the judgment of trained panelists.

 /  5
Disintegration

Disintegration

Disintegration reflects the amount of time needed for a sheet to break up in swirling water.

 /  5
Tearing ease

Tearing ease

Tearing ease is based on the separation of sheets at their perforation.

 /  5
Rapid Dissolving
Toilet paper
Shop
Strength

Strength

Strength reflects resistance to puncturing.

 /  5
Softness

Softness

Softness is the judgment of trained panelists.

 /  5
Disintegration

Disintegration

Disintegration reflects the amount of time needed for a sheet to break up in swirling water.

 /  5
Tearing ease

Tearing ease

Tearing ease is based on the separation of sheets at their perforation.

 /  5
bath tissue
Toilet paper
Shop
Strength

Strength

Strength reflects resistance to puncturing.

 /  5
Softness

Softness

Softness is the judgment of trained panelists.

 /  5
Disintegration

Disintegration

Disintegration reflects the amount of time needed for a sheet to break up in swirling water.

 /  5
Tearing ease

Tearing ease

Tearing ease is based on the separation of sheets at their perforation.

 /  5
Premium Ultra Soft
Toilet paper
Shop
Strength

Strength

Strength reflects resistance to puncturing.

 /  5
Softness

Softness

Softness is the judgment of trained panelists.

 /  5
Disintegration

Disintegration

Disintegration reflects the amount of time needed for a sheet to break up in swirling water.

 /  5
Tearing ease

Tearing ease

Tearing ease is based on the separation of sheets at their perforation.

 /  5
Ultra Soft
Toilet paper
Shop
Strength

Strength

Strength reflects resistance to puncturing.

 /  5
Softness

Softness

Softness is the judgment of trained panelists.

 /  5
Disintegration

Disintegration

Disintegration reflects the amount of time needed for a sheet to break up in swirling water.

 /  5
Tearing ease

Tearing ease

Tearing ease is based on the separation of sheets at their perforation.

 /  5
Green Earth Bath Tissue (Walmart)
Toilet paper
Shop
Strength

Strength

Strength reflects resistance to puncturing.

 /  5
Softness

Softness

Softness is the judgment of trained panelists.

 /  5
Disintegration

Disintegration

Disintegration reflects the amount of time needed for a sheet to break up in swirling water.

 /  5
Tearing ease

Tearing ease

Tearing ease is based on the separation of sheets at their perforation.

 /  5
Ultra Soft & Thick (Walmart)
Toilet paper
Shop
Strength

Strength

Strength reflects resistance to puncturing.

 /  5
Softness

Softness

Softness is the judgment of trained panelists.

 /  5
Disintegration

Disintegration

Disintegration reflects the amount of time needed for a sheet to break up in swirling water.

 /  5
Tearing ease

Tearing ease

Tearing ease is based on the separation of sheets at their perforation.

 /  5
Ultra Strong & Soft (Walmart)
Toilet paper
Shop
Strength

Strength

Strength reflects resistance to puncturing.

 /  5
Softness

Softness

Softness is the judgment of trained panelists.

 /  5
Disintegration

Disintegration

Disintegration reflects the amount of time needed for a sheet to break up in swirling water.

 /  5
Tearing ease

Tearing ease

Tearing ease is based on the separation of sheets at their perforation.

 /  5