Your membership has expired

The payment for your account couldn't be processed or you've canceled your account with us.

Re-activate

Save products you love, products you own and much more!

Save products icon

Other Membership Benefits:

Savings icon Exclusive Deals for Members Best time to buy icon Best Time to Buy Products Recall tracker icon Recall & Safety Alerts TV screen optimizer icon TV Screen Optimizer and more

    Best Refrigerators Without a Water and Ice Dispenser or an Icemaker

    These refrigerators maximize storage space and forgo features that tend to break

    When you shop through retailer links on our site, we may earn affiliate commissions. 100% of the fees we collect are used to support our nonprofit mission. Learn more.

    LG LT18S2100W, Haier QJS15HYRFS, and Maytag MSS25N4MKZ refrigerators on blue background
    Water dispensers and icemakers consistently cause the most complaints among refrigerator owners in CR’s member surveys.
    Photos: Manufacturers

    Refrigerators with a built-in water dispenser, a water and ice dispenser, or an icemaker are popular, but those features often underperform or are downright faulty. In our latest surveys—conducted between 2014 and 2024—Consumer Reports found that 19 percent of refrigerators have trouble making ice and 16 percent of those that come with a dispenser have problems making water or ice. 

    One option: Forgo the icemaker and water dispenser altogether.

    In this article Arrow link
    More on Refrigerators

    While that may sound like a simple solution, we’ve found it can actually be quite difficult. Most refrigerators on the market have at least an icemaker. But if you don’t care about the features, it’s still worth making the effort to find a model without either. That extra effort has another advantage, too.

    “Icemakers and water dispensers take up a lot of space inside the refrigerator,” says Breann Chai, who oversees CR’s refrigerator testing. “If you get a model without them, you’ll be able to maximize your storage space.”

    CR members can read on for ratings and reviews of the best refrigerators without either a water dispenser or an icemaker from our tests. There are two top-freezers, two bottom-freezers, two side-by-sides, and two French-doors, from Beko, Haier, LG, Maytag, Midea, Samsung, and Whirlpool. 

    See our refrigerator buying guide to learn more about different refrigerator configurations. Check our complete refrigerator ratings to view our full list of CR-tested fridges.

    Best Top-Freezer Refrigerators Without a Water and Ice Dispenser or an Icemaker

    These two top-freezer refrigerators from Samsung and LG come without a water dispenser, an ice dispenser, or an icemaker.

    Best Bottom-Freezer Refrigerators Without a Water and Ice Dispenser or an Icemaker

    These two bottom-freezer refrigerators from LG and Beko come without a water dispenser, an ice dispenser, or an icemaker.

    Best Side-by-Side Refrigerators Without a Water and Ice Dispenser or an Icemaker

    These two side-by-side refrigerators from Whirlpool and Maytag come without a water dispenser, an ice dispenser, or an icemaker.

    Best French-Door Refrigerators Without a Water and Ice Dispenser or an Icemaker

    These two French-door refrigerators from Haier and Midea come without a water dispenser, an ice dispenser, or an icemaker.

    How CR Tests Refrigerators

    In CR’s refrigerator lab, our engineers wire up models with thermocouples and monitor the refrigerators for more than a month in a climate-controlled chamber. They collect more than 5.4 million temperature readings for each model to detect warm and cold spots—for CR’s temperature-uniformity test—and determine which refrigerators keep food fresh longer.

    In addition, Consumer Reports’ member surveys allow us to create predicted reliability and owner satisfaction ratings. All this data informs our overall refrigerator ratings, which include more than 250 models. For more information on CR’s refrigerator tests, see how we test refrigerators. To learn more about the different types of refrigerator configurations, see our refrigerator buying guide. And for our highest-rated picks across categories—including French-door refrigerators and mini fridges—look at our guide to the best refrigerators of the year


    Daniel Wroclawski

    Dan Wroclawski is a home and appliances writer at Consumer Reports, covering products ranging from refrigerators and coffee makers to cutting-edge smart home devices. Before joining CR in 2017, he was an editor at USA Today’s Reviewed, and launched the site’s smart home section. In his spare time, you can find him tinkering with one of the over 70 connected devices in his house. Follow Dan on Facebook and X: @danwroc.