Donate |

Car backup cameras

Aftermarket systems add convenience and safety

Last updated: January 2014

Accessory backup video systems for cars are widely available with several electronics manufacturers competing in the market. While the primary mission of these minicams is simply to provide a view to the rear while you're parking or backing up, they also offer a safety advantage because they can help you to see a child, pet, or hazard.

Our previous tests of a few aftermarket models found that performance generally tracked with price—another case of "you get what you pay for." That said, even the worst performers are better than a beeper-type parking aid at seeing objects or people behind the vehicle.

Why you need to eliminate the blind zone

Every year, thousands of children are hurt or killed because a driver backing up didn't see them. The safety advocacy group Kids and cars calculates that two children are killed and 48 are seriously injured this way every week in the United States. For the most part, back-over incidents take place in residential driveways or parking lots and about three-quarters of the time it is a parent or close relative who's behind the wheel.

The main reason that back-over accidents are so frequent is that every vehicle has a rear blind zone—the area you can't see from the driver's seat. And that zone to the rear is bigger than you might think, ranging from about 25 feet for a minivan to 50 feet for some pickup trucks--plenty of space for an unwary child to be in harm's way. (Read: The danger of blind spots.)

Many new cars have proximity sensors that beep with increasing frequency when you back toward solid objects. The sensor systems might work well as parking aids but they aren't informative enough to tip you to the presence of someone, particularly a small child.

Other vehicles have backup cameras incorporated into their ($2,000 to $3,000) navigation system and some appear in the rear-view mirror. When you shift into reverse, the screen shows a wide-angle or fish-eye view to the rear. Camera systems are much better at revealing objects you could not otherwise see through the windows and mirrors.

Aftermarket sensor and camera systems allow any vehicle to be retrofitted with some sort of warning device.

How they work

Aftermarket backup cameras have adopted various designs. A small video camera is sometimes built into a license-plate holder or mounted in a trailer-hitch receiver or on a car's bumper.

Systems typically use a video screen built into a replacement rearview mirror, an accessory add-on monitor for the existing mirror, or a flat screen that mounts to the inside of the sun visor. Some systems are wireless, but most require wiring that snakes through the vehicle from the camera to the system's video display and on to the car's electric power system. Complicated, hard-wired systems are best installed by a professional.

Besides scouting for children, a camera mounted near, or in, the rear bumper can come in handy if you're trying to mate up your vehicle with a trailer. With a camera showing you where the hitch actually is, there's less need for a helper to call out directions to you.

None of the systems we've tested is ideal. The parking-sensor systems aren't discriminating enough to act as a truly useful safety device. Those that use a display built into an inside mirror seem promising, because the mirror is a natural place to look when you're backing up. But their display is often small, or indistinct, and the add-on mirror assemblies can be quite bulky. The viewing area from some cameras is quite narrow, and some cameras are prone to fogging up too easily.

Still, any camera system is more informative than a mere proximity sensor.

How to choose

Aftermarket companies offer three types of backup systems: rearview cameras, sensor systems, and wide-angle lenses. Use to decide which best suits your needs. For wired camera and sensor systems, we recommend professional installation.

No matter what type of system you choose, consider the following when deciding on a specific model:

Know how the device mounts on your vehicle

Camera and sensor systems that are mounted on the vehicle's bumper or bodywork might require drilling. They might not be the best choice if you lease your vehicle.

If you have a trailer hitch, you can consider a model that mounts in the hitch receiver. But you would have to remove the system to use your trailer.

Other camera and sensor models mount on the license-plate frame. But some states prohibit frames because they can obscure the plate.

Within types, features vary

That is especially true with the sensor models we tested. The ultrasonic systems were generally the most sensitive, but their performance was adversely affected by rain, snow, or other inclement weather.

The microwave-based sensor systems we tested were not affected by weather but are less sensitive as a group. They also don't warn the driver unless the vehicle or object behind it is moving.

The display quality of the camera-based models is very good, although it doesn't match that of the larger screens on some carmakers' integrated navigation systems. All of the system displays turn on when the vehicle shifts into reverse.

All the systems we tested are potentially useful. They're a good complement to looking around the vehicle before entering, and checking the rear window and rearview mirror just before and while moving in reverse.

   

E-mail Newsletters

FREE e-mail Newsletters!
Choose from cars, safety, health, and more!
Already signed-up?
Manage your newsletters here too.

Latest From Consumer Reports

SAVE AT THE SUPERMARKET
8 ways to keep rising prices from eating into your budget Some food is more expensive, but there are ways to cut costs when you shop.
CHAIN SAW REVIEWS
Get out your chain saw because 'Sharknado 2' is hereVideo This time you can create an interactive light show while watching at home.
SAVE ON CAR RENTALS
Head-to-head in car-rental wars: Zipcar vs. Hertz Is Zipcar's innovative approach to renting a car a good deal for you?
CAR SEAT REVIEWS
6 best new convertible seats for your toddlerVideo Our tests will help you find the best seat for your growing child.
DIGITAL CAMERA REVIEWS
5 questions to ask before you buy a point-and-shoot Your answers can help you determine what your camera needs are.
CARS NEWS
Why Toyota should recall the Camry Hybrid Brake problems on 2007-11 models warrant a stronger company response.

Connect

and safety with
subscribers and fans

Follow us on:

Cars

Cars New Car Price Report
Find out what the dealers don't want you to know! Get dealer pricing information on a new car with the New Car Price Report.

Order Your Report

Mobile

Mobile Get Ratings on the go and compare
while you shop

Learn more