Donate |
Preview: To see full article and/or Ratings, Subscribe Now!

Who makes the best cars?

Subaru replaces Honda atop the automaker report cards

Consumer Reports Magazine: April 2012

Subaru’s score of 75, two points higher than last year, reflects better test scores for such redesigned models as the Impreza, Legacy, and Outback over the last few years. The 2012 Impreza, which we just tested, now tops the small-sedan class and is our Top Pick in that category. Subaru’s average road-test score of 82 is the highest in our analysis. Moreover, all of Subaru’s models now have at least average reliability, thanks to fewer problems with the sporty Impreza WRX.

By contrast, Honda has been hurt by several redesigned models—including the Civic and Odyssey—that didn’t measure up to their predecessors. Honda’s overall score dropped by two points and its average road-test score dropped one point. Honda models, however, are still among the most reliable on the road overall.

Here are other highlights from this year’s analysis:

  • Mazda shows the most dramatic improvement among the 13 manufacturers. It climbed to second place from last year’s seventh and increased its overall score by nine points. It was helped by an improved Mazda3 and the shedding of two models that dragged down its score, the Tribute SUV and RX-8 sports car.

  • Buoyed by consistently above-average reliability and high test scores, Toyota is among the top three automakers for the fifth straight year. The redesigned 2012 Camry helped Toyota’s average road-test score climb to 76, from last year’s 74.

  • Although Chrysler remains in last place, its overall score jumped eight points, making it the second most improved automaker. Chrysler’s average road-test score also increased by eight points, the most of any automaker, and its overall reliability improved to average. The turnaround can be credited mostly to Chrysler’s extensively freshened and redesigned vehicles.

  • Ford falls the farthest, dropping from fifth place in last year’s report cards to 10th. The automaker’s road-test score improved by two points over last year’s, but subpar reliability of some new vehicles, due largely to the troublesome MyFord Touch infotainment system and Power-Shift automatic transmission, hurt its report-card grade.

  • In our testing, we continue to see improvement in General Motors’ redesigned models, but reliability of some new vehicles is below average.

  • Many top-rated automakers, including Subaru, Mazda, Volvo, and Hyundai, have narrower product lines that lack big SUVs and trucks, which tend to score lower in our tests. But we found that dated models had more effect on a manufacturer’s ranking than did product diversity.

  • Hyundai and Kia continue to introduce new models that do well in our testing. Each automaker’s overall score is based on an equally weighted composite of roadtest and predicted-reliability scores for all of its models that we’ve tested. The road tests comprise more than 50 individual evaluations, covering performance, safety, fuel economy, comfort, convenience, interior quality, and more. The predicted reliability scores come from our latest Annual Auto Survey, which drew 1.3 million responses from Consumer Reports subscribers.

Sign In or Subscribe to see full article and/or Ratings.

E-mail Newsletters

FREE e-mail Newsletters!
Choose from cars, safety, health, and more!
Already signed-up?
Manage your newsletters here too.

Latest From Consumer Reports

SAVE AT THE SUPERMARKET
8 ways to keep rising prices from eating into your budget Some food is more expensive, but there are ways to cut costs when you shop.
CHAIN SAW REVIEWS
Get out your chain saw because 'Sharknado 2' is hereVideo This time you can create an interactive light show while watching at home.
SAVE ON CAR RENTALS
Head-to-head in car-rental wars: Zipcar vs. Hertz Is Zipcar's innovative approach to renting a car a good deal for you?
CAR SEAT REVIEWS
6 best new convertible seats for your toddlerVideo Our tests will help you find the best seat for your growing child.
DIGITAL CAMERA REVIEWS
5 questions to ask before you buy a point-and-shoot Your answers can help you determine what your camera needs are.
CARS NEWS
Why Toyota should recall the Camry Hybrid Brake problems on 2007-11 models warrant a stronger company response.

Connect

and safety with
subscribers and fans

Follow us on:

Cars

Cars New Car Price Report
Find out what the dealers don't want you to know! Get dealer pricing information on a new car with the New Car Price Report.

Order Your Report

Mobile

Mobile Get Ratings on the go and compare
while you shop

Learn more