Cars that can save your life

2015 AUTOS SPOTLIGHT

Cars that can save your life

One of the best things about 2015 cars? The safety devices that help stop crashes before they start.

Published: March 09, 2015 04:10 PM

Although self-driving cars are years away, some of their souped-up features are already available on contemporary cars—and can save you from a crash. Those crash-avoidance systems can let a car “see” other vehicles or pedestrians well before they are in your line of sight, anticipate some types of collisions, automatically apply the brakes to avoid a crash, and prevent you from crossing lanes into the path of another car.

Some systems, such as forward-collision warning, have been around for several years on luxury cars but are filtering down to mainstream vehicles. Others, such as steering assist, are just getting ready for prime time.

1,700,000
That's the estimated number of rear-end collisions that occur annually.

The life-saving potential of crash-avoidance systems is great enough that the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) tests them as part of its safety evaluations. As of 2015, vehicles must both excel in crash tests and have a front-crash warning system with automatic braking to be named an IIHS Top Safety Pick Plus. In addition, that “autobrake” has to function effectively in formal track tests that IIHS conducts.  

The government’s National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) is considering making some of the systems mandatory. NHTSA vehicle-safety information shows which systems are available by model, but those features don’t yet influence the agency’s 5-Star Safety Ratings.  

Cost can still be an obstacle. Most advanced systems today come only as part of an options package or on higher-trim versions. We think it’s worth the extra cost if you can afford it.

What our tests found

The crash-avoidance systems rely on a variety of sensors, cameras, lasers, short- and long-range radar, or combinations of cameras and radars.

Computers monitor what’s going on and, when appropriate, prompt some action from the car or the driver.

Those actions may start with attention grabbers, such as a beep, a flashing dashboard icon, or such “haptic” signals as a tug from the seat belt or a vibration in the seat or steering wheel. The more advanced systems can apply partial or full braking force if the driver doesn’t respond.

In our evaluations, we’ve found that there’s a fine line between a helpful copilot and a computerized backseat driver. If a warning system emits too many inappropriate or false alerts, the temptation is to switch it off. Although some autonomous braking systems are more effective than others, there’s a net benefit regardless.

100 fatalities and 204,000 injuries could be prevented by forward-crash-avoidance technologies, according to NHTSA estimates.

“Even in the cases where these systems failed to prevent a crash, if there’s automatic braking going on, or if the driver does brake in response to a warning, that crash is going to be less severe than it would have been otherwise,” says David Zuby, IIHS chief research officer.

The technology isn’t perfect. Camera systems can be baffled by bad weather. Radars can see through rain and fog, but they aren’t as discerning as cameras, and road muck can block them. In the end, those systems can prevent a lot of crashes from happening. But it’s important to realize that none of the aids reduces the need to stay alert.

Visit our free car safety guide for a detailed listing of the systems by automaker.

Why you need it—or not

Some new cars have these crash-avoidance systems; others don’t. Our experts tell which are worth getting.

Rear camera

Rear-visibility technology (such as backup cameras) will become mandatory in May 2018. They can help prevent a back-over accident, such as hitting a child who wanders behind your car.

CR’s view: Cameras are a must-have on SUVs and pickups, which often have large blind zones behind them. They’re also great for backing into tight parking spaces or lining up a trailer hitch.

Forward-collision warning (FCW) and autobrake

Also called a precrash-mitigation system, these stand-alone or combined radar-, laser-, or camera-based systems peer ahead and warn drivers of an impending collision by using visual, auditory, or physical cues. Some also precharge the brakes and take other steps to prepare for impact. If the driver ignores the warnings, systems with autonomous braking will apply partial or full braking force. Some can respond at anywhere from walking to highway speeds.

CR’s view: We prefer systems that let you adjust your follow distance. If you are looking for a new car, get one with FCW.

Blind-spot monitoring and assist

A blind-spot-monitoring system uses radars or cameras to scan the areas beside and behind you, looking for vehicles entering or lurking in your blind zones. When such a vehicle is detected, an illuminated icon appears in or near the appropriate side-view mirror.

If you signal a turn while a car is in your blind zone, some systems send a stronger alert, such as a blinking light or louder chirps. More advanced systems help keep you in your lane by applying the brakes on one side of the vehicle.

CR’s view: In general, we like these and find them helpful.

Rear cross traffic

Most systems use radar sensors that are mounted on each side of the rear bumper. When the car is reversing, the system scans for hazards approaching from the sides. Good systems can detect bicyclists and people with shopping carts. It can warn by flashing the blind-spot indicators or sounding a warning tone.

CR’s view: This is a system that has made most of us say, “Whew.”

Adaptive headlights

Adaptive headlights swivel as you turn the steering wheel, which helps illuminate the road when going around curves. A 2014 IIHS study found that adaptive headlights improved drivers’ reaction times by about a third of a second. That could be just enough to avoid hitting a parked car on a dark road.

CR’s view: Our drivers have mixed feelings about adaptive headlights. The wider view can be helpful, but the swiveling motion of the light path can be a little distracting, especially if the headlight beams’ motion isn’t exactly synchronized with the steering wheel’s.

Lane-departure warning (LDW) and steering assist

This mostly uses cameras with processing software to pick up lane markers and monitor your distance from them. If you stray over the line without signaling, you’ll hear a warning tone or feel a physical alert such as a vibration in the steering wheel or seat. More advanced “lane- keeping assist” (LKA) systems selectively apply brakes or nudge the steering to guide you back if you’re wandering.

CR’s view: We’ve found LDW more useful on highways than on narrow, winding country roads, where they can alert you too often. We also prefer systems that make corrections using the steering rather than the brakes.

Pedestrian detection and braking

Pioneered by Volvo and now offered by others, pedestrian detection can recognize a person straying into a vehicle’s path. Some systems will automatically apply the brakes, if needed, partially or to a complete stop. Some newer systems can also detect bicyclists.

CR’s view: A good investment, especially if you often drive in populous areas.

Drowsiness detection

Various technologies determine whether a driver is tired or falling asleep. Alerts may include a chime, a dab on the brakes, a tug on the shoulder belt, and/or an illuminated cup-of-coffee icon on the instrument panel.

CR’s view: We haven’t experienced any problems, such as false alarms, on cars we’ve tested with this feature.

In addition to drowsy driving, the systems can detect if you’re wandering around in your lane. Some may prevent drivers from looking down to text or e-mail.

Sign up for the free monthly Cars e-mail newsletter from Consumer Reports!

(Consumer Reports will not sell or rent your email address to third parties. See our Privacy Policy.)

Thank you. Your registration is complete!

Check your inbox for the most recent edition of the Cars e-mail newsletter.

Safest cars on the road

For 2015, vehicles that score as an IIHS Top Safety Pick Plus had to earn at least an Acceptable rating in the small-overlap front-crash test and a Good rating in all other crash tests. In addition, they had to have a front-crash-prevention system equipped with an automatic emergency-braking (autobrake) feature that earns an advanced or superior rating in their front-crash-prevention ratings. All are 2015 models.

Small cars

Lexus CT 200h Subaru XV Crosstrek
Mazda3 Toyota Prius
Subaru Impreza  

Midsized cars

Chrysler 200 Subaru Outback
Mazda6 Toyota Camry
Subaru Legacy Toyota Prius V

Small SUVs

Honda CR-V
Mitsubishi Outlander
Mazda CX-5
Subaru Forester

Midsized SUV

Toyota Highlander
 

Luxury SUVs

Acura MDX
Mercedes-Benz M-Class
Lexus NX Volvo XC60

Luxury cars

Acura TLX Infiniti Q50
Audi A3 Volvo S60
BMW 2 Series
Volvo V60

Large luxury cars

Acura RLX Lexus RC
Hyundai Genesis
Mercedes-Benz E-Class
Infiniti Q70 Volvo S80

Minivan

Toyota Sienna  

Best at automatic emergency braking

These 2015 models had the best IIHS collision-avoidance and -mitigation scores based on the superior performance of their forward-collision-warning systems with autobrake. Not all of these are Top Safety Picks.

Acura TLX Mercedes-Benz C-Class
BMW 5 Series
Mercedes-Benz E-Class
BMW X5 Mercedes-Benz M-Class
Buick Regal Mercedes-Benz GLK
Cadillac CTS Subaru Forester
Cadillac SRX Subaru Impreza
Cadillac XTS Subaru Legacy
Chevrolet Impala Subaru Outback
Chrysler 200 Subaru XV Crosstrek
Honda CR-V Volvo S60
Hyundai Genesis Volvo S80
Infiniti Q50 Volvo V60
Infiniti Q70 Volvo XC60
Jeep Cherokee  

These didn’t pass the crash test

The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety’s 40-mph, small-overlap frontal-crash test has proved to be a tough challenge. The 2015 models below score Poor, posing an unacceptable threat of “injury” to the driver dummy. CR won’t recommend any vehicle that scores a Poor in this test.

Audi A4 Kia Sportage
Chrysler Town & Country
Lincoln MKS
Dodge Grand Caravan Mazda CX-9
Fiat 500 Mazda5
Fiat 500L Mitsubishi Mirage
Ford Escape Nissan Juke
Honda Pilot Nissan Leaf
Hyundai Accent Nissan Quest
Hyundai Tucson Nissan Versa
Jeep Patriot Toyota Prius C
Editor's Note:

This article also appeared in the April 2015 issue of Consumer Reports magazine.



E-mail Newsletters

FREE e-mail Newsletters! Choose from cars, safety, health, and more!
Already signed-up?
Manage your newsletters here too.

Cars News

Connect

and safety with
subscribers and fans

Follow us on:

Cars

Cars Build & Buy Car Buying Service
Save thousands off MSRP with upfront dealer pricing information and a transparent car buying experience.

See your savings

Mobile

Mobile Get Ratings on the go and compare
while you shop

Learn more