Donate |

Mythbuster: EMF levels in hybrids

Consumer Reports News: August 04, 2010 08:08 AM

Some concern has been raised about the possible health effects of electromagnetic field radiation, known as EMF, for people who drive in hybrid cars. While all electrical devices, from table lamps to copy machines, emit EMF radiation, the fear is that hybrid cars, with their big batteries and powerful electric motors, can subject occupants to unhealthy doses. The problem is that there is no established threshold standard that says what an unhealthy dose might be, and no concrete, scientific proof that the sort of EMF produced by electric motors harms people in the first place.

Taken together, the many studies of EMF radiation and human health have been inconclusive. A major analysis of study results, published by the National Institutes of Health in 2002, said that “the overall scientific evidence for human health risk from EMF exposure is weak.”

That hasn’t stopped the debate. While studies continue, so does a highly charged argument on Internet forums and elsewhere, between those who see serious risk and those who dismiss such claims out of hand. Without taking sides, we conducted a study of our own, not to settle the question about human health risk but to measure EMF levels in the hybrid cars in our test fleet. We took readings from five hybrids and eight conventional vehicles.

Test findings:
We found the highest EMF levels in the Chevrolet Cobalt, a conventional non-hybrid small sedan.

To conduct our measurements we used a sophisticated three-axis ELF/Magnetic Field meter. That gave us readings in milligaus units, the commonly accepted measure for magnetic fields. We measured EMF levels on all 13 vehicles under the same conditions. We took measurements at the driver’s right foot, knee, waist, and head when idling and driving around our simulated stop-and-go city-driving course, and while accelerating from 0 to 60 mph.

Vehicle tested Peak EMF reading at driver's feet (milligauss)
2008 Chevrolet Cobalt 30 mG
2008 Chevrolet Tahoe Hybrid 14 mG
2008 Subaru Impreza 6 mG
2006 Toyota Prius (hybrid) 4 mG
2008 Subaru Legacy 4 mG
2008 Toyota Prius (hybrid) 4 mG
2008 Mini Cooper Clubman 3 mG
2008 Nissan Altima Hybrid 3 mG
2008 Toyota Highlander Hybrid 2 mG
2008 Nissan Murano 1.3 mG
2008 Toyota Sequoia 1 mG
2007 Chevrolet Suburban 0.8 mG
2008 Toyota Highlander 0.5 mG

Here are some highlights from the tests:

  • For all vehicles, EMF readings were highest in the driver’s foot well and second-highest at the waist, much lower higher up, where human organs might be more susceptible to EMF. Typically, peak readings were highest under braking.
  • Some hybrid cars had readings similar to conventional cars. For instance, the Mini Cooper Clubman registered a maximum of 2 milligaus and the Toyota Prius 2.05. The 2008 Subaru Legacy exhibited 2.5 mG.
  • The Toyota Highlander hybrid had a peak reading of 0.6 mG and an average of 0.4 mG measured at waist level while the regular Highlander measured a nearly identical 0.5 peak and 0.45 average mG there.
  • The Chevrolet Tahoe Hybrid measured as much as 14 milligaus, but the conventional and otherwise similar Suburban only showed 0.8.
  • Among the 13 vehicles tested, the Chevrolet Cobalt had the highest peak readings, 30 mG at the feet and 16 mG at the knee.

We can’t say whether the EMF levels we measured have any significance to people’s health or not. Even the highest reading we got, 30 mG in the Cobalt, doesn’t seem that high in the grand scheme of things.

Some may raise a specter of doubt, though, since part of the electric and magnetic fields in hybrid cars come from an alternating-current motor rather than the presumably less threatening direct-current used in conventional cars. To get a sense of scale, though, note that users of personal computers are subject to EMF exposure in the range of 2 to 20 mG, electric blankets 5 to 30 mG, and a hair dryer 10 to 70 mG, according to an Australian government compilation. In this country, several states limit EMF emissions from power lines to 200 mG. However, there are no U.S. standards specifically governing EMF in cars.

In this series of tests, we found no evidence that hybrids expose drivers to significantly more EMF than do conventional cars. Consider this myth, busted.

Visit our guide to alternative fuels and guide to fuel economy.

Gabe Shenhar and Gordon Hard with Eric Evarts

Updated 8/8/10

   

E-mail Newsletters

FREE e-mail Newsletters! Choose from cars, safety, health, and more!
Already signed-up?
Manage your newsletters here too.

Cars News

Connect

and safety with
subscribers and fans

Follow us on:

Cars

Cars New Car Price Report
Find out what the dealers don't want you to know! Get dealer pricing information on a new car with the New Car Price Report.

Order Your Report

Mobile

Mobile Get Ratings on the go and compare
while you shop

Learn more