Your membership has expired

The payment for your account couldn't be processed or you've canceled your account with us.

Re-activate

Talking Cars 520: Driving the Ineos Grenadier

Plus, our experts weigh in on whether it’s worth fixing an older BMW when the repairs cost more than the car itself

Main theme: Ineos says the Grenadier was designed to be “the best vehicle in the world at under 5 mph.” In other words, this thing is all about serious off-roading. With origins rooted in a discussion in a pub in London, England, in 2017, the goal of startup automaker Ineos Automotive was to build an even more uncompromising vehicle than the Land Rover Defender

Although the Grenadier has been on sale globally since 2023, this was our first time driving one. Still, we wanted to find out how good it is off-road, and how many compromises drivers have to make on the road. 

Interestingly, the Grenadier uses a BMW-sourced 3.0-liter turbocharged inline-six engine with 282 hp and 332 lb.-ft. of torque. Power is sent to the road through an eight-speed automatic transmission and permanent four-wheel drive. We borrowed the Station Wagon from Ineos. (There is also a Quartermaster pickup truck.) The Station Wagon starts at $71,750, but the Fieldmaster version we borrowed, which included a fair amount of options, cost $89,555 with the $1,995 destination charge.

Our experts spent a couple of weeks in the Grenadier, driving it on paved roads, rough dirt roads, and, of course, we took it up the vaunted Consumer Reports Rock Hill at our 327-acre Auto Test Center. And yes, it’s awesome off-road. We discuss the overall driving experience, the vehicle’s unusual steering, noisy cabin, quirky controls, and whether we’d actually buy one for ourselves. 

Audience question: I love my 2014 BMW 328d, but it needs emissions system repairs that will cost more to fix than the vehicle is worth. What are my options for offloading a car that won’t pass emissions tests in many states? 

Talking Cars 520 podcast panel Ineos Grenadier
'Talking Cars' panelists (from left): Mike Monticello, Stef Schrader, and Ryan Pszczolkowski.

Photo: Consumer Reports Photo: Consumer Reports

How to Listen to the Podcast

Talking Cars episodes are available through Apple Podcasts (audio or video), SpotifyYouTube, and on CR.org/video.

Engage in the Talking Cars community.

Recent Podcast Episodes

All Questions Episode (self-driving, spare tires), episode 519
• Driving the Lexus ES Electric Sedan, episode 518
• Driving the 2026 Volkswagen Jetta GLI, episode 517
• Is Your Car Getting a ‘Kill Switch’ in 2027?, episode 516
• Why Are Cars Turning Into Smartphones?, episode 515

Have a Question?

Send a text or video message to TalkingCars@iCloud.com. Please include your first name and where you’re from. If we feature it in a future episode, we’ll send you an exclusive Auto Test Center T-shirt!

Talking Cars

Browse the complete podcast archive for past shows.


Mike Monticello

Mike Monticello is the manager of road tests and reviews for the autos team at Consumer Reports. He has been with CR since 2016. Mike has been evaluating and writing about cars for nearly 25 years, having previously worked at Road & Track magazine and Edmunds.com. On the weekends, he usually switches from four wheels to two, riding one of his mountain bikes or motorcycles. Follow him on X: @MikeMonticello.