Subaru Outback

An extensive 2010 redesign brought major changes to Subaru's practical all-wheel-drive wagon version of their Legacy sedan. Considerably larger than before, interior space grew to include a rear seat that can comfortably fit three adults, and the cabin became quieter. Cargo space and driver visibility are both generous. A new continuously variable transmission (CVT) notably improved fuel economy; we measured 24 mpg overall with the standard 2.5-liter four-cylinder. The 3.6-liter six-cylinder is smoother and quicker, at the expense of about two mpg. A manual transmission is also available on more basic trims.

More agile handling and nicer interior quality marked the Outback's 2005 redesign. Practical and sure-footed in snowy weather, thanks to standard all-wheel-drive, the Outback is a Legacy with added ground clearance and a slightly raised roof. Thin roof pillars and large windows make for easy outward visibility. Ride comfort is impressive, but cabin noise can be annoying, particularly with the four-cylinder. Everyday handling is responsive, though the car can slide its tail out in emergency maneuvers. For many years, only 3.0 VDC versions got standard electronic stability control; this spread slowly to other trims, with all Outbacks finally getting this desirable safety feature by 2009.

Essentially a Legacy with more ground clearance and a higher roof, Subaru's Outback is a popular SUV alternative. Standard all-wheel-drive is a plus on slippery roads. While most Outbacks are wagons, a sedan version was also available. The ride is steady and absorbent, and other than some wind noise, it is relatively quiet inside. Nicely weighted steering aids handling, but it doesn't feel as crisp as the Legacy. The rare and pricey 3.0 VDC model has a stability control system that marginally improves the otherwise twitchy emergency handling.