Exclusive: First 3D TV tests uncover best, worst sets

We've just posted our first-ever Ratings of 3D TVs. The best of the bunch do a terrific job displaying realistic, in-your-face three-dimensional images, but some of the sets fall short for 3D and could make you feel like you're suffering from double vision, as we recently explained. Also, see our video: 3D TV testing (at right).

Our 3D TV Ratings (available to subscribers) include 20 LCD TV and plasma TV sets ranging in size from 46 inches to 65 inches and in price from $1,400 to $4,500. All of them were able to convey a sense of depth and dimensionality, but some did much better than others at presenting well-defined images with sharp, clear edges. On other TVs, we saw a hint of ghosting around the edges, which was very distracting in some scenes. That took away from the realism of the 3D effect.

There's not much 3D content yet—a number of Blu-ray discs and a few TV channels—but we expect more in 2011. Keep in mind that you can also watch regular HD programming on these TVs. Most tested models did a great job in that regard, as our Ratings show, and a few of the plasma sets were among the best HD performers we've seen. And for photo enthusiasts with a 3D camera or camcorder, a compatible 3D TV is the ideal display. It's by far the best way to see your 3D photos and home movies.

Sales of 3D TVs haven't been great, so retailers are cutting prices and offering value-packed promotional bundles with a Blu-ray player, glasses, and a few Blu-ray discs. If you find a well-rated model at an attractive price, it might be worth considering—even if you have no plans to watch 3D just yet. You'll have a great TV with lots of features and the option of watching 3D if and when you have the inclination to do so.

But we don't encourage everyone to rush out to buy a 3D TV right now given the shortage of 3D content and the need to wear glasses that aren't all that comfortable. Bide your time if you don't need a new TV and you're not dying for a feature that you might not use very often. Soon there'll be more 3D TVs from which to choose, lower prices, more content on disc and from broadcasters, and maybe even cheaper and more comfortable glasses.