Subaru Forester

Name: 2009 Subaru Forester
Brand: Subaru

EPA MPG: 22 mpg

Owner Reported MPG:

EPA MPG: 22 mpg

Owner Reported MPG:

RECALL ALERT: There are 18 recalls on this vehicle. Learn More.

There are 18 recalls on this vehicle. Learn More.

RECALL ALERT: There are 18 recalls on this vehicle. Learn More.

There are 18 recalls on this vehicle. Learn More.

Reliability Details

Owner Satisfaction Details

See All Ratings & Specs

Road Test

The Forester is among the best of the small SUVs. Its cabin is quiet with very good fit and finish and a roomy backseat. Safety equipment includes standard curtain airbags and stability control. Crash-test results are excellent. Forester also has the most comfortable ride of any small SUV, yet it is agile and handles securely.

2009 SUVs Reliability

This Car

100

0 - 100

Subaru Forester

vs. Similar Cars

Ford Escape

Honda CR-V

Honda Element

Nissan Rogue

Toyota RAV4

See All Models Reliability

Crash Tests

IIHS Front Moderate Overlap

Good

IIHS Front Small Overlap, Driver

IIHS Side Crash

Good

NHTSA Overall Crash

NHTSA Overall Frontal-Crash

NHTSA Overall Side-Crash

See All Ratings & Specs

Owner Reports

Owner Satisfaction

2000

2001

2002

2003

2004

2005

2006

2007

2008

2009

2010

2011

2012

2013

2014

2015

2016

2017

2018

2019

2020

2021

2022

2023

2024

2025

Driving Experience

Comfort

Value

View all Owner Satisfaction

Subaru vs. Other New Car Brands

See How All Brands Stack up

Crash Tests

IIHS Front Moderate Overlap

Good

IIHS Front Small Overlap, Driver

IIHS Side Crash

Good

NHTSA Overall Crash

NHTSA Overall Frontal-Crash

NHTSA Overall Side-Crash

See All Ratings & Specs

Subaru vs. Other New Car Brands

See How All Brands Stack up

Crash Tests

IIHS Front Moderate Overlap

Good

IIHS Front Small Overlap, Driver

IIHS Side Crash

Good

NHTSA Overall Crash

NHTSA Overall Frontal-Crash

NHTSA Overall Side-Crash

See All Ratings & Specs

Subaru vs. Other New Car Brands

See How All Brands Stack up

2009 Compact SUVs Ratings

2009 Subaru Forester

$4,150 - $5,300

EPA MPG 22 mpg

Road test

Reliability

Owner Satisfaction

2009 Chevrolet Equinox

$3,075 - $3,725

EPA MPG 21 mpg

Road test

Reliability

Owner Satisfaction

2009 Dodge Nitro

$2,925 - $5,250

EPA MPG 19 mpg

Road test

Reliability

Owner Satisfaction

2009 Ford Escape

$3,225 - $4,450

EPA MPG 20 mpg

Road test

Reliability

Owner Satisfaction

2009 Ford Escape Hybrid

$3,225 - $4,450

EPA MPG 28 mpg

Road test

Reliability

Owner Satisfaction

2009 Honda CR-V

$5,950 - $6,700

EPA MPG 24 mpg

Road test

Reliability

Owner Satisfaction

2009 Honda Element

$6,275 - $7,750

EPA MPG 23 mpg

Road test

Reliability

Owner Satisfaction

2009 Hyundai Tucson

$3,475 - $5,000

EPA MPG 21 mpg

Road test

Reliability

Owner Satisfaction

2009 Infiniti EX

$5,250 - $5,775

EPA MPG 19 mpg

Road test

Reliability

Owner Satisfaction

2009 Jeep Compass

$3,025 - $3,325

EPA MPG 24 mpg

Road test

Reliability

Owner Satisfaction

2009 Jeep Liberty

$3,225 - $4,125

EPA MPG 17 mpg

Road test

Reliability

Owner Satisfaction

2009 Jeep Patriot

$3,025 - $3,300

EPA MPG 22 mpg

Road test

Reliability

Owner Satisfaction

2009 Kia Sportage

$3,675 - $4,275

EPA MPG 21 mpg

Road test

Reliability

Owner Satisfaction

2009 Mazda Tribute

$2,875 - $4,125

EPA MPG NA

Road test

Reliability

Owner Satisfaction

2009 Mercury Mariner

$2,975 - $4,200

EPA MPG 28 mpg

Road test

Reliability

Owner Satisfaction

2009 Mitsubishi Outlander

$3,000 - $4,325

EPA MPG 22 mpg

Road test

Reliability

Owner Satisfaction

2009 Nissan Rogue

$2,925 - $3,250

EPA MPG 23 mpg

Road test

Reliability

Owner Satisfaction

2009 Nissan Xterra

$4,350 - $5,675

EPA MPG 18 mpg

Road test

Reliability

Owner Satisfaction

2009 Saturn Vue

$2,800 - $4,125

EPA MPG NA

Road test

Reliability

Owner Satisfaction

2009 Suzuki Grand Vitara

$3,575 - $5,050

EPA MPG 21 mpg

Road test

Reliability

Owner Satisfaction

2009 Toyota FJ Cruiser

$10,900 - $12,750

EPA MPG 19 mpg

Road test

Reliability

Owner Satisfaction

2009 Toyota RAV4

$6,050 - $7,075

EPA MPG 23 mpg

Road test

Reliability

Owner Satisfaction

2009 Volkswagen Tiguan

$2,900 - $3,975

EPA MPG 20 mpg

Road test

Reliability

Owner Satisfaction

See All Compact SUVs Ratings

Features & Specs

4-door SUV

2 front, 3 rear

AWD

2.5-liter 4 (170 hp)
2.5-liter 4 turbo (224 hp)

5-speed manual
4-speed automatic

Join Consumer Reports cu. ft.

In most cases, automotive warranties are based on the vehicle identification number (VIN), and the warranty will be valid regardless of ownership. The dealership can tell you exactly how much warranty is left.

Read more about extended warranties

See All Ratings & Specs

Model History

2025-Present

Current Generation

The redesigned 2025 Subaru Forester incorporates a host of new and improved safety technology onto a stiffened chassis that the automaker says helps achieving a quieter ride. Although the aesthetic presence of the new model skews more brawny--thanks to a beefier grille, more squinty headlamps, pronounced and plastic-cladded fender arches, and distinct haunches--it's no surprise that cosmetic changes are relatively minor. The Forester has been a winner for Subaru, providing owners with standard all-wheel drive, big, high-visibility windows, and easy utility. Now the automaker has enhanced its standard active safety features with pedestrian and cyclist detection and a rear seat occupant alert system, and offers driver monitoring and emergency steering as optional equipment. A more fuel-efficient hybrid and off-road focused Wilderness versions are available.

2019-2024

2019 Redesign Year

Over its various iterations, Subaru has had a winning formula with the Forester. The 2019 redesign builds upon that and is even better. This popular small SUV delivers a combination of roomy interior, excellent visibility, commendable fuel economy, simple controls, comfortable ride and responsive handling. The 2.5-liter four cylinder, combined with the continuously variable automatic transmission yielded 28 mpg overall, which is among the best in class. But acceleration isn't exhilarating and the engine's noise isn't the most pleasant. The cabin is roomy with a particularly generous rear seat and very easy access. The controls are simple to use including the infotainment system which is also compatible with Android Auto and Apple CarPlay. The EyeSight suite of forward collision warning, automatic emergency braking, lane departure warning, and lane keeping assist is standard. Updates for 2020 include a standard rear-seat reminder system. A mild freshening for 2022 includes a revised exterior and the addition of an off-road oriented Wilderness trim with additional ground clearance and all-terrain tires.

2014-2018

2014 Redesign Year

Few cars are as logical as the Subaru Forester, further reinforced by a 2014 redesign. Upright and boxy, big windows and thin pillars supply excellent driver visibility, while large doors deliver easy access. Rear seat room is spacious, and there is plenty of cargo space. Even with the standard all-wheel-drive, fuel economy from the 2.5-liter four-cylinder engine and continuously-variable transmission (CVT) tops the class at 26 mpg overall; a manual transmission is standard. A turbocharged XT model is available, sacrificing some fuel economy, but delivering more effortless power. Handling is nimble enough and very secure, but the Forester isn't particularly sporty to drive. Ride comfort lost some of the cushiness of earlier Foresters, but it still offers decent isolation from road bumps. Indeed, luxury isn't part of the equation for this no-nonsense car. Interior furnishings are fairly basic and the cabin can be noisy. The standard cloth front seats come up short on support, but the optional leather ones are better. The 2014-2015 Foresters have either a rather rudimentary infotainment system or a particularly confounding optional navigation system. The Starlink touchscreen system introduced for 2016 brought Subaru into modern times, with full-featured connectivity that is much easier to use. Crash-test performance is impressive and the affordable EyeSight suite of safety gear adds forward-collision warning and automatic emergency braking; we recommend getting this system.

2009-2013

2009 Redesign Year

Subaru's popular Forester made considerable gains with its 2009 second-generation redesign. Stability control and curtain airbags finally became standard, and a much roomier rear seat comfortably fits adults. Improvements in ride comfort gave the Forester perhaps the best ride of any small SUV, and handling is nimble and secure. Road noise is quieter than in earlier Foresters, but remains notable. Cabin fittings and controls are spartan but serviceable. The standard 2.5-liter four-cylinder provides adequate acceleration and 22 mpg overall. Look for effortless acceleration from the turbocharged XT version, but it only gets 20 mpg on required premium fuel. Performance and economy would be better without the antiquated four-speed automatic transmission. The manual transmission returns 24 mpg with the base engine. Comfort improves on higher-end models with their telescoping steering wheel and power-adjustable leather seats.

2003-2008

2003 Redesign Year

Practicality reigns with the Subaru Forester. Its boxy body supplies plenty of space, big windows for abundant visibility, and easy loading of people and cargo. Standard all-wheel-drive works well on slippery roads. Sharp steering makes the Forester agile to drive, and it rides very comfortably. Road noise grows old on long trips and the interior looks rather basic. Handling can be a bit tricky at its limits and only the turbocharged models offer stability control. Standard is a 2.5-liter four-cylinder providing good acceleration and 21-22 mpg overall. XT versions have a turbocharged four-cylinder that matches the acceleration of many V6s; expect 20 mpg on premium fuel.

1998-2002

1998 Redesign Year

The Forester, new for 1998, is one of the better small car-based SUVs. It is derived from the good-performing Subaru Impreza, but the Forester touts a taller and roomier cargo compartment and more ground clearance. We find the ride compliant and handling nimble. Matched to a responsive automatic transmission, the 2.5-liter four-cylinder engine provides good acceleration. Like all newer Subarus, it has an effective AWD system. The rear seat is a bit cramped, but the cabin has lots of storage compartments.