These models won—or broke—hearts, according to our Owner Satisfaction Survey, which asked people whether they would buy the same car again. 

CategoryMost-satisfyingLeast-satisfying
Subcompact Cars

Honda Fit1

Kia Rio1

Compact Cars

Volkswagen Golf1

Nissan Sentra

Midsized Cars

Subaru Legacy1

Nissan Altima
Large CarsChrysler 300Ford Taurus
Luxury Compact Cars

Audi A31

Infiniti Q50

Mercedes-Benz CLA

Luxury Midsized/Large CarsTesla Model S

Acura RLX

Cadillac XTS

Sporty CarsChevrolet Corvette

Hyundai Genesis Coupe1

MinivansHonda OdysseyNissan Quest
Small SUVsSubaru Forester

Jeep Compass1

Jeep Patriot

Midsized SUVs

Kia Sorento1

Dodge Journey

Large SUVs

Ford Expedition1

Chevrolet Traverse/
GMC Acadia

Luxury Compact SUVs

Porsche Macan1

Mercedes-Benz GLA1

Luxury Midsized/Large SUVs

Acura MDX1

Infiniti QX60
Pickup Truck

Ford F-1501

Nissan Frontier
    *Based on one model year of data instead of the usual three years.

Editor's Note: This article also appeared in the April 2016 issue of Consumer Reports magazine.