Product Reviews

Welcome to Consumer Reports.

We’re so glad to have you as a member. You now have access to benefits that can help you choose right, be safe and stay informed.
Young people at a party with a wireless speaker in a dorm room.

Best Wireless Speakers for Dorm-Room Style

Some of these fun models light up, doubling as accent lamps for campus living

College kids (and, of course, their high school siblings) tend to be short on both space and cash, but they're not short on opinions when it comes to dorm-room style. That's where this crop of stylish wireless speakers from recent Consumer Reports testing comes in.

These models each make a strong aesthetic statement while cranking out summer hits, like Kacey Musgraves' "High Horse." They're perfect speakers for a dorm room. And four of them can double as an accent light that can make studying for Chem 101 just a bit more tolerable.

1
Post-Modern Lava Lamp
JBL Pulse 3

JBL Pulse 3

What looks a little like a lava lamp and plays music really well? Meet the JBL Pulse 3. This Bluetooth speaker channels the look of those groovy 1960s relics, but it uses LEDs under a plastic dome—instead of heated waxy blobs—for its visual effects. That should make the campus fire marshal happy.

 

It can also do things that no lava lamp can dream of. You can customize the patterns and colors of its light show through the JBL app, and even match the color palette to a throw pillow or your favorite T-shirt.

 

The Pulse 3 also performed well in our sound quality tests, earning a recommendation from our testers with good bass impact and smooth trebles. Stereo pairing is an option, but the Pulse 3 can also be synced with up to 100 other Pulse 3s using JBL's Connect+ protocol. Imagine that party.

 

JBL claims an IPX7 water-resistance rating for the Pulse 3, which means that it should withstand immersion in up to a meter of water for up to 30 minutes—CR doesn't test speakers for water-resistance, though. No word about how the speaker will stand up to a spilled beer.  

    2
    Just Beat It
    Sony SRS-XB31

    Sony SRS-XB31

    How about a speaker that you can not only play music on but also make music on? The Sony SRS-XB31 features what the company calls a Party Booster, which plays a variety of percussion sounds when you strike the sides and top of the enclosure. So you can play along with the music. The feature wasn't as responsive as it might have been, though, and of course it's more of a fun novelty than a necessity.

     

    The XB31 also features cool lighting effects—a multicolored LED that changes color with the beat, accented by two white strobes. It's a nice look.

     

    The XB31 is recommended by our testers, largely on the basis of its sound quality. Though the XB stands for, um, "eXtra Bass," that was a bit of a mischaracterization. Our testers found that percussion instruments were reproduced with realistic sharpness and impact, but the deepest bass was limited by the speaker's modest size.

     

    Despite its tweedy fabric covering (available in five colors), the XB31 features an IP67 rating, which means that it should keep out both dust and water, to a claimed depth of 1 meter for 30 minutes. (We don't test speakers for water resistance.) That should be sufficient to withstand the rigors of most dorm rooms, even on a Saturday night. 

      3
      Bass-ic Black
      Harman Kardon Onyx Studio 4

      Harman Kardon Onyx Studio 4

      Unlike the other speakers listed here, the Harman Kardon Onyx 4 does not light up. But it does make a striking visual statement with an oversized round shape and "none-more-black" hue. It looks like a cross between a throw pillow and a giant black M&M. The Harman Kardon logo on the back (which is also a functional part of the speaker) puts on its own little show, vibrating frantically with the beat when you're blasting Beyonce. 

       

      Our testers liked the way the Onyx sounds, with bass that reached into the lowest registers while providing pop on drums and bass. And while it's not quite as party-friendly as some of the other models in this roundup, at least when it comes to water-resistance, the Onyx 4 does play plenty loud.

       

      If you're interested in the Onyx 4, some savvy shopping could save you serious coin. Though the retail price is a quite spendy $450 on the company's website and at Best Buy, the Onyx 4 routinely sells for less than half that. Its current Amazon price is a mere $150. You can put a lot of cash into the Late Night Pizza Fund with the difference.

        4
        Sometimes Less Is Just Less
        Sony SRS-XB21

        Sony SRS-XB21

        Sony's SRS-XB21 is the smaller sibling to the XB31, which received a Best Buy rating from our testers. But unfortunately, the family resemblance doesn't extend to its sonic performance.

         

        The XB21 wears the same tweedy covering as the XB31, and it's similarly water-resistant. However, its LED light feature doesn't change color, and it's simply less fun than its higher-end sibling. It does include the same Party Booster feature—if you hit the speaker it produces percussion sounds that can accent the music.

        But the major drawback of the XB2 is its sound. Our testers rated it only Fair at reproducing music, noting that much of the fine detail that brings music to life was obscured, and some singers sounded a bit like they had a cold. Unless you're on a super-tight budget, it's worth spending the extra $50 for the much-better-sounding XB31. 

          5
          Beefy but Below-Average Sound
          BeFree Sound Dual 12" (BFS-4600)

          BeFree Sound Dual 12" (BFS-4600)

          Don't let appearances deceive you. The BeFree Sound Dual has the look of a serious piece of public address equipment, from its massive, knee-high beefy plastic shell to its roller-bag-style wheels and collapsible handle.

           

          The problem, our testers discovered, is that the sound doesn't come close to living up to the speaker's beefy aesthetics. For example, what seems to be a large speaker cone is really just a flashing LED disco light.

           

          Sonically, the BeFree ranked near the bottom of our ratings. Its bass was surprisingly subdued for such a large speaker, and the midrange reproduced voices with a "thin and plasticky" quality. Our testers also reported that the unit made faint chirping sounds whenever it was on.

           

          The BeFree does include a boatload of features, including microphone, guitar, and RCA inputs, and even a wireless remote. But while we all love bells and whistles, the primary job of a speaker is to make music sound great. The BeFree doesn't accomplish that. 

            Shopping links are provided by eBay Commerce Network and Amazon, which makes it easy to find the right product from a variety of online retailers. Clicking any of the links will take you to the retailer's website to shop for this product. Please note that Consumer Reports collects fees from both eBay Commerce Network and Amazon for referring users. We use 100% of these fees to fund our testing programs.
            Allen St. John

            I believe that technology has the power to change our lives—for better or for worse. That's why I’ve spent my life reporting and writing about it for outlets of all sorts, from newspapers (such as the Wall Street Journal and the New York Times) to magazines (Popular Mechanics and Rolling Stone) and even my own books ("Newton’s Football" and "Clapton’s Guitar"). For me, there's no better way to spend a day than talking to a bunch of experts about an important subject and then writing a story that'll help others be smarter and better informed.